Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie: A Dreamy Delight

Oh, let me tell you about my absolute weakness—Amish peanut butter cream pie. The first time I tried it at a church potluck, I nearly swooned! That velvety peanut butter filling, the way it melts on your tongue… and the best part? No oven required. Just mix, chill, and boom—you’ve got a dessert that’ll have everyone begging for seconds.

What makes this pie so special is its ridiculous simplicity. Five minutes of mixing, a few hours in the fridge, and you’re left with a creamy, dreamy slice of heaven. My kids call it “peanut butter cloud pie” because the texture is that light yet rich. And when drizzled with chocolate? Forget about it—this is the pie dreams are made of.

Table of Contents

Why You’ll Love This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Trust me, this pie is a game-changer. Here’s why it’s going to become your go-to dessert:

• No-bake magic: Skip the oven—this pie comes together in minutes with just a bowl and a spoon.
• Ultra-creamy texture: The combo of peanut butter, cream cheese, and whipped topping is like a cloud of pure peanut butter bliss.
• Crowd-pleaser: Whether it’s a potluck or a family dinner, this pie disappears faster than you can say “seconds, please!”

Once you try this Amish peanut butter cream pie, you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it.

Ingredients for Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Here’s all you need to make this dreamy pie—and trust me, you probably have most of this in your pantry already! The magic happens with:

• 1 pre-baked 9-inch pie crust (store-bought or homemade—no judgment here!)
• 1 cup creamy peanut butter (I use Jif for that perfect smoothness)
• 1 cup powdered sugar (sifted if you’re feeling fancy)
• 1 (8 oz) package cream cheese, softened (leave it out for 30 minutes—no shortcuts!)
• 1 (12 oz) container frozen whipped topping, thawed (Cool Whip works miracles)
• 1 tsp vanilla extract (the real stuff, please)
• ½ cup milk (whole milk makes it extra creamy)
• Chocolate syrup or chopped peanuts for garnish (optional but highly recommended)

See? Nothing weird or complicated—just simple ingredients that transform into something extraordinary.

How to Make Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Step 1: Blend the Peanut Butter and Cream Cheese

First things first—grab your softened cream cheese and peanut butter. I use my trusty hand mixer for this step, but a sturdy whisk works too. Beat them together until they’re completely smooth and creamy. Don’t rush it—this step sets the foundation for that dreamy texture. But be careful not to overmix, or you’ll risk losing that perfect consistency.

Step 2: Incorporate Sugar and Vanilla

Now, here’s where the sweetness comes in. Gradually add the powdered sugar, about a quarter cup at a time, mixing well after each addition. This keeps lumps at bay and ensures everything blends evenly. Once the sugar’s in, drizzle in that vanilla extract. It’s like a little flavor hug for your peanut butter filling—trust me, you’ll taste the difference.

Step 3: Fold in Whipped Topping

This is where the magic happens. Take your thawed whipped topping and gently fold it into the peanut butter mixture. I use a spatula and make big, sweeping motions to keep it light and fluffy. Overmixing here is the enemy—you want to keep that airy texture intact. It’s like folding clouds into peanut butter heaven.

Step 4: Chill and Garnish

Pour that luscious filling into your pre-baked pie crust and smooth the top with a spatula. Now, here’s the hard part—waiting. Pop it in the fridge for at least 4 hours (overnight is even better) to let it set. When it’s time to serve, drizzle with chocolate syrup or sprinkle with chopped peanuts for that extra wow factor. Trust me, it’s worth every second of patience!

Print

Tips for the Perfect Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

After making this pie more times than I can count, I’ve picked up some tricks that take it from good to “oh-my-goodness-I-need-another-slice” amazing:

• Peanut butter matters: Natural peanut butter gives a deeper peanut flavor with less sweetness—perfect if you prefer a less sugary dessert. Learn more about different types of peanut butter.
• Patience pays off: That 4-hour chill time? Bare minimum. Overnight refrigeration gives you the dreamiest, firmest texture.
• Temperature is key: Make sure your cream cheese is truly softened—cold cream cheese leaves stubborn lumps.
• Go gentle: When folding in whipped topping, think of it like tucking a baby into bed—light and loving.

Follow these tips, and your Amish peanut butter cream pie will be the star of any dessert table!

If you love rich, old-fashioned desserts, you’ll definitely want to check out our Absolute Best Coconut Cream Pie Recipe next. It’s another silky, homemade pie that’s guaranteed to impress your guests and bring a touch of nostalgia to your dessert table.

Ingredient Substitutions and Variations

Listen, life happens—sometimes you’re out of an ingredient or want to mix things up. Here’s how you can tweak this Amish peanut butter cream pie without losing that magic:

• Crust swap: Graham cracker crust works beautifully if you want that sweet crunch contrast.
• Milk alternatives: Almond milk or oat milk substitute just fine if you’re dairy-free.
• Crunchy twist: Use chunky peanut butter if you love texture (I won’t tell Grandma).
• Decadent upgrade: Stir mini chocolate chips into the filling before chilling for a Reese’s cup effect.

The beauty of this pie? It’s forgiving—as long as you keep that peanut butter love front and center!

Serving and Storing Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Here’s my favorite way to serve this beauty – straight from the fridge with a hot cup of coffee. The contrast between cold, creamy pie and steaming coffee is pure magic. For parties, I’ll slice it while chilled but let it sit at room temperature for about 10 minutes first – just enough to soften slightly for that perfect spoonful.

Storage couldn’t be easier! Cover any leftovers (ha!) with plastic wrap or transfer slices to airtight containers. It keeps beautifully in the fridge for 3 days – though in my house, it never lasts that long. Pro tip: If you’re making it ahead, wait to add garnishes until right before serving to keep everything fresh and pretty.

Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Nutritional Information

Now let’s talk numbers—but remember, these are estimates that’ll vary depending on your specific brands and measurements. Here’s the scoop per slice (and let’s be honest, who stops at just one?):

• Calories: Around 420 per slice (worth every one!)
• Fat: 28g (most comes from that glorious peanut butter)
• Sugar: 28g (it’s dessert, after all)
• Protein: 8g (peanut butter packs a punch)

Want to lighten it up? Try reduced-fat cream cheese or sugar-free whipped topping. But personally? I say embrace the indulgence—this pie’s meant to be enjoyed!

And don’t forget to follow us on Pinterest for more Amish-style dessert ideas, classic pie recipes, and mouthwatering baking inspiration you’ll want to save for later!

Frequently Asked Questions

Share Your Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie Experience

I’d love to hear how your pie turned out! Did you add any fun twists? Maybe you discovered a new garnish trick? Drop a comment below—I read every one. And if you snapped a photo, tag me on social media so I can drool over your creation!